HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) State legislators received a firsthand
look Tuesday at why critics say Pennsylvania's open-records law is
too weak: In front of them, the state's top highway official
reversed a decision his agency had made to withhold bridge safety
ratings from the public.
As part of a hearing on proposed changes to the open-records
law, the House State Government Committee had requested testimony
from the Department of Transportation on why it refused to release
bridge safety reports to a newspaper that had asked for them
several months ago.
With the collapse of a major bridge in Minnesota last week,
bridge safety is a high-profile issue across the country, and
Transportation Secretary Allen D. Biehler told legislators he would
release the reports despite concerns the information would cause
undue alarm.
``It's simply a judgment call,'' Biehler told the panel. ``I'd
rather err on the side of providing information.''
Critics of the state's open-records law say that, among other
things, it gives officials at all levels of government wide
latitude to deny public records requests, a loophole they say has
helped make Pennsylvania one of the worst public-access states in
the country.
The seeming capriciousness of PennDOT's decision to withhold,
then release the bridge safety reports was not lost on Carl Lavin,
a deputy managing editor of The Philadelphia Inquirer.
Lavin, who testified after Biehler, said the Philadelphia School
District had refused to release a consultant's report on student
violence against teachers until a teacher was seriously injured
by a student and the Inquirer planned a story about the district's
refusal to release the report.
``Miraculously, that report became available,'' Lavin told
legislators. ``A judgment call, just as you saw today.''
(Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)