HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) The Pennsylvania League of Women Voters
has clearly struck a nerve with its lawsuit against former state
Chief Justice Ralph Cappy.
Time will tell if it's more serious than that.
In its filing in U.S. District Court, the usually low-profile
good-government group paints a disturbing scenario in which Cappy's
Supreme Court may have negotiated a secret deal that provided
generous pay raises for judges in exchange for upholding the
state's 2004 slot-machine gambling law.
The league, a plaintiff in the slots-law challenge that the
court rejected, says such a deal or, if there wasn't a deal, the
fact that many legislators believed there was one violated its
due-process rights in the slots case.
''The case presents the fairly unremarkable and simple argument
that secret discussions by judges with those who had interests then
pending before them poses the appearance and risk of impropriety,
and thus compromises the due process we expect of our judicial
system as Americans,'' said league director Bonita Hoke.
Reaction from the state's high court was swift and indignant.
Cappy was a vocal advocate of higher salaries for the state's
1,000 judges, arguing that the increases were necessary to compete
with private firms for top legal talent. He said the allegations
have ''absolutely no truth'' and are based on ''falsehoods,
speculation and innuendo.''
''I intend to defend myself vigorously in court,'' Cappy, who
left the court at the end of last year and is now a partner in a
Pittsburgh law firm, said in a statement issued through the
Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts.
The suit also mentions Ronald Castille, Cappy's successor as
chief justice.
It says an unnamed House member encountered Castille at a
Harrisburg restaurant before the court ruled on the slots
challenge, inquired about its status and received a ''wink and
nod'' from Castille that the representative interpreted as a signal
that the law would be upheld.
Castille said the lawsuit ''slanders the entire Supreme Court''
and suggested that the league and its lawyer might be subject to
official sanctions or disciplinary actions.
Naturally, any lawsuit that links allegedly improper and
possibly illegal activity to two of the most important state laws
enacted in recent memory is a magnet for media attention. The
question is whether the league's lawsuit can survive intense
judicial scrutiny.
The slots law has spawned what is expected to be a
multibillion-dollar gambling industry, much of it still on the
drawing board, that is financing property-tax cuts for Pennsylvania
homeowners. The court upheld the slots law on June 22, 2005.
Barely two weeks later, the Legislature passed the pay-raise law
including not only the judicial raises but increases of as much
as 54 percent for legislators in a middle-of-the-night vote that
provoked a strong public backlash. Lawmakers responded by repealing
the law four months later, but the Supreme Court restored the
judicial raises only in September 2006.
One potential problem with the lawsuit is that it is based
primarily on hearsay from unidentified legislators, who could
simply be embellishing rumors that circulated during the pay-raise
debate.
The allegations in the lawsuit were widely discussed in the
Capitol during that time period, said Michael Greer, a leader of
Pennsylvanians Against Gambling Expansion Fund Inc., the lead
plaintiff in the slots-law challenge.
''At that time, pinning them down and attributing them to a
specific source proved difficult, but it raised doubts in the minds
of many people as to whether there would be a fair result in the
case,'' he said.
League lawyer Paul Rossi said Cappy's accusers would be
identified in court.
''I anticipate we will be calling (many) current and former
state legislators as witnesses,'' Rossi said.
Another obstacle for the league will be persuading U.S. District
Judge Yvette Kane to accept a case involving state issues.
Two years ago, Kane threw out a suit challenging the
Legislature's handling of the pay-raise law, saying it's up to
Pennsylvania voters to decide whether to retain or oust their
legislators.
John Burkoff. a University of Pittsburgh law professor who
teaches and writes about legal ethics, called the lawsuit
''irresponsible.''
''This kind of due-process argument is simply not something that
courts have recognized to this point and it's not something that
courts are likely to recognize,'' said Burkoff, suggesting that any
alleged judicial misconduct should be handled through the court's
disciplinary process.
Peter Jackson is the Capitol correspondent for The Associated
Press in Harrisburg. He can be reached at pjackson(at)ap.org
(Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)