PHILADELPHIA (AP) After years of legal wrangling, Web site
publishers and free-speech advocates argued in court Monday that a
law Congress passed to protect children from online pornography was
fatally flawed.
Salon.com, Nerve.com and other plaintiffs said the 1998 Child
Online Protection Act would likely criminalize legitimate material
they publish, from sexual health information to erotic literature
to news photographs of naked prisoners tortured at Abu Ghraib.
The Justice Department argues that it is easier to stop online
pornography at the source than to keep children from viewing it,
inadvertently or otherwise.
The law, signed by then-President Clinton, requires Web sites to
get credit card information or some other proof of age from adults
who want to view material that may be considered ``harmful to
children.'' It would impose a $50,000 fine and six-month prison
term on commercial Web site operators that allow minors to view
such content, which is to be defined by ``contemporary community
standards.''
The American Civil Liberties Union, which represents the
plaintiffs, argues that filters are a more effective way of
policing the Internet. It notes that the law would not regulate any
material posted overseas.
The plaintiffs also argued that the term ``community standards''
is too vague.
``As a parent, I know that what's fine for my daughter may not
be appropriate even for some of her friends,'' testified Joan
Walsh, editor-in-chief of Salon.com.
Eric Beane, a government attorney, acknowledged that it is
tempting to defer to families on the question of what is
appropriate for children, but said the patchwork of filters used by
parents don't work.
``The evidence will show that a shocking amount of pornography
slips through to children,'' Beane said in opening statements.
The nonjury trial in front of Senior U.S. District Judge Lowell
A. Reed Jr. is expected to take about a month.
The 1998 law has yet to be enforced. The U.S. Supreme Court
upheld a preliminary injunction, ruling in June 2004 that the
plaintiffs were likely to prevail.
The plaintiffs, technology experts and even Supreme Court
Justice Anthony M. Kennedy have expressed concerns that the law has
already been surpassed by technology and the growth of the
Internet. Kennedy noted, for example, that filters can block Web
material posted offshore, but the disputed law cannot control what
foreigners post online.
The government ``will argue that parents are too stupid to use
filters. It's an insulting argument and it's wrong,'' ACLU attorney
Chris Hansen said in his opening statement.
Nerve.com founder Rufus Griscom said requiring viewers to submit
a credit card or jump through other hoops before viewing the site
would cut traffic and advertising revenues to disastrous
levels.
``Based on what I've heard today, I think moving overseas would
be a possibility,'' Griscom testified.
In preparing for its defense of the law, the Justice Department
sought internal files from search engine companies and Internet
service providers. Google Inc. refused one such subpoena for 1
million sample queries and 1 million Web addresses in its database,
although it primarily cited trade secrets, not privacy issues.
A federal judge in California sharply limited the amount of
information Google had to surrender.
(Copyright 2006 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)