Traffic:   4 Incidents
Weather: 49°F Go
Current Time:  04:15pm, 01/06/08
AP News

Minn. appeals court overturns ruling compelling reporter to turn over notes

Monday, December 24, 2007
By BRIAN BAKST
Associated Press Writer

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) An appeals court on Monday struck down a ruling ordering a reporter to give prosecutors unpublished notes from an interview with a man who shot two police officers before killing himself.

Mankato Free Press reporter Dan Nienaber was one of the last people to speak with Jeff Skjervold, 41, who shot and injured two police officers during a Dec. 23, 2006, standoff at his home.

District Court Judge Norb Smith ruled that Nienaber had to turn over his unpublished notes to Blue Earth County prosecutors, who were investigating the incident.

But the Minnesota Court of Appeals panel ruled that prosecutors did not prove they had a compelling enough reason to seize Nienaber's notes.

``Essentially, the county attorney argues that it needs to conduct discovery to find an injustice, but declines to connect the discovery to a particular injustice,'' appeals court Judge Christopher Dietzen wrote. ``We conclude that the statute requires that the particular injustice be identified.''

The ruling was a rare test of the state's reporter shield law, which protects reporters from having to identify sources or reveal unpublished information. Mark Anfinson, an attorney for the newspaper, said the fact that few cases are brought under the shield law adds to the importance of each ruling.

``This decision reminds everyone who might think about using a subpoena against a journalist that those circumstances are very narrow,'' he said.

County Attorney Ross Arneson said his office has not decided whether to appeal.

ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
AP State Wire