CHICAGO (AP) A federal appeals court upheld former Gov. George
Ryan's racketeering and fraud conviction Tuesday, but he will be
allowed to remain free on bond while his lawyers make a fresh
appeal.
The 73-year-old former governor, once the state's most powerful
Republican, had been under a court order to report to prison within
72 hours of the failure of his appeal.
But the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals relented and allowed
him to remain free while his lawyers press their case for a
rehearing before all 11 actively serving appeals judges.
Earlier Tuesday, a panel of the appeals court brushed aside
claims by defense attorneys that jury deliberations at Ryan's trial
had been fatally flawed and that the guilty verdict should be
overturned.
His attorneys were filing for a rarely granted ``en banc''
hearing that would have the entire appeals court hear the appeal,
said longtime Ryan supporter James R. Thompson, another former
Illinois governor whose law firm, Winston & Strawn, represented
Ryan for free.
``Gov. Ryan obviously is disappointed,'' Thompson said. But he
said, ``No court ever deprived a defendant of his life and liberty
under these circumstances and that is an argument we will make if
necessary to the U.S. Supreme Court.''
Ryan was convicted last year of racketeering conspiracy, fraud
and other offenses for taking payoffs from political insiders in
exchange for state business while he was Illinois secretary of
state from 1991 to 1999 and governor for four years after that.
Prosecutors said he had steered state contracts and leases to
insiders and used tax dollars in his political campaigns.
In his appeal, Ryan's attorneys argued that the jury's
deliberations were flawed.
U.S. District Judge Rebecca R. Pallmeyer had replaced two jurors
with alternates after deliberations in the case had already
started, and the defense said unauthorized documents brought into
the jury room poisoned the deliberations.
The appellate panel disagreed Tuesday in a 2-1 decision.
``The fact that the trial may not have been picture perfect is,
in itself, nothing unusual,'' Judge Diane Wood wrote in the
majority opinion, joined by Judge Daniel Manion.
Judge Michael Kanne dissented and said Ryan and his
co-defendant, businessman-lobbyist Larry Warner, should get a new
trial. He called the jury deliberations ``dysfunctional.''
Ryan and Warner both maintain they did nothing illegal.
The investigation into the men began as a probe of bribes
exchanged for commercial drivers licenses in Illinois. It ballooned
into a wide-ranging investigation of corruption when Ryan was a
major political power at the Statehouse in Springfield and led to
dozens of convictions of state officials, lobbyists, driving
instructors and others.
At the same time, Ryan was also being praised by capital
punishment foes for suspending executions in the state and clearing
Illinois' death row.
Ryan's appeal of his conviction was largely based on the
decisions by Pallmeyer to replace the two jurors after
deliberations had started. The dismissed jurors had been found to
have omitted mention on pre-trial questionnaires that they had been
in trouble with the police.
``The high profile nature of these proceedings gave rise to some
unusual problems with the jury, but we are satisfied that the court
handled them acceptably,'' the appeals court said.
(Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)