Traffic:   5 Incidents
Weather: 45°F Go
Current Time:  04:45am, 10/13/07
AP News

Judge's refusal to keep office open violated rights of inmate later executed, attorneys argue

Friday, October 12, 2007

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) High-profile lawyers are accusing a state judge of violating the rights of a condemned inmate by cutting off appeals once office hours ended, leading to his execution.

Convicted killer Michael Richard was put to death the evening of Sept. 25 after Sharon Keller, Texas Court of Appeals presiding judge, ordered a clerk to close the office promptly at 5 p.m.

Keller last week noted to the Houston Chronicle that Richard's lawyers did not file their request on time, saying they had all day. She did not return a phone call to her office from The Associated Press this week.

Twenty lawyers, including a state representative and a former appellate judge, on Wednesday filed a complaint against her with the State Commission on Judicial Conduct. They say Keller improperly cut off appeals even though the U.S. Supreme Court had earlier in the day accepted a case on the propriety of lethal injection.

The case the Supreme Court accepted had direct implications for Richard's execution, the lawyers argued.

Richard, 49, was executed for the 1986 rape and fatal shooting of a mother of seven.

His lawyers called the court's clerk the day he was to be executed, asking that the office stay open an extra 20 minutes so a request to delay the execution could be filed.

Even if the stay were denied by the Texas court, that state request was needed procedurally to get a stay from the Supreme Court. But Keller ordered a clerk to close the office, and Richard was executed later that evening.

Richard's lawyers did not file their appeal during business hours because of computer trouble and pressure in responding to the Supreme Court ruling, Jim Harrington, director of the Texas Civil Rights Project, said Friday night. The project is representing the lawyers who filed the complaint.

Judge Cheryl Johnson, the appeals court jurist in charge of Richard's case, said she heard nothing about the clerk's office closing off the appeal until the next day.

She said she understood that in a death penalty case, court officials remain at the office until the time of execution and accept filings until the execution is under way.

The lawyers' complaint also argues that Keller's action ``brought the integrity of the Texas judiciary and of her court into disrepute and was a source of scandal to the citizens of the state.''

The lawyers included former State Bar President Broadus Spivey, University of Houston law professor Mike Olivas, former appellate Judge Michol O'Connor and Democratic state Rep. Harold Dutton of Houston.

Keller's actions were ``morally callous, shocking and unconscionable for an appellate judge,'' Harrington said.

The judicial conduct commission's proceedings are secret. The commission can dismiss a complaint without making it public, publicly reprimand a judge or recommend to the Texas Supreme Court that the judge be removed from office.

ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
AP State Wire