MINNEAPOLIS (AP) A consultant for the state Transportation
Department recommended installing high-tech sensors to detect
cracking on critical sections of an interstate bridge less than a
year before the span collapsed, killing 13 people, records show.
The recommendation made in a November 2006 report was considered
but the agency ultimately went with other kinds of inspections
because there were no signs of cracking on bridge trusses, said Dan
Dorgan, a state bridge engineer.
``In the absence of cracks, we had no locations to monitor or
information to orient monitors for crack detection,'' Dorgan wrote
in response to written questions from The Associated Press.
The cause of the Aug. 1 collapse, which also injured about 100
people, is under investigation.
In the years leading up to the collapse, the state DOT and
private consultants performed numerous evaluations and inspections
of the bridge that raised concerns about its condition. The DOT
contracted with URS Corp. in 2003 to perform a more thorough
analysis of fatigue in the bridge support structure.
The AP reviewed nearly 13,000 pages of documents obtained under
an open records request relating to the URS Corp. contract.
The company indicated in its study of the bridge between 2004
and 2006 that there were 20 fracture critical truss beams on the
bridge those considered to be ``the most susceptible locations
for crack initiations.''
The URS study recommended an acoustic emission monitoring system
that included the capability of alerting the state DOT immediately
about specific locations on the bridge ``where unusual signals are
detected indicating the possibility of steel cracking.''
Mark Carlos, president of Physical Acoustics Corporation, which
makes such monitors, said there's no way to know whether such
monitors would have detected the impending bridge collapse.
Acoustic emission monitoring differs from the way bridges are
typically inspected; it detects cracks while they are occurring,
instead of trying to spot them after they've happened, Carlos said.
The cost of installing the monitors in a specific area of a
bridge, as was proposed by URS, would cost between $20,000 to
$40,000, Carlos said. The devices are used on some bridges around
the country but are not yet common, he said.
Dorgan said that DOT inspectors instead utilized ultrasonic
testing, which he called a ``proven means of actually detecting
cracks.''
Ron Low, a spokesman for URS, said that the company would not
comment on any of the findings or recommendations related to its
inspections of the bridge.
Two Minnesotans sued the state Transportation Department
Tuesday, claiming its $234 million contract with Flatiron
Constructors of Longmont, Colo., is illegal and harms taxpayers.
Flatiron's bid was the most expensive and tied for the longest
amount of time, but the company beat three other teams on a
technical score that accounted for factors such as quality and
aesthetics.
In their lawsuit filed in Ramsey County District Court, the
plaintiffs seek to void the contract.
DOT spokeswoman Lucy Kender said it would be inappropriate for
anyone at the agency to discuss a pending lawsuit.
Associated Press writers Elizabeth Dunbar in Minneapolis and
Martiga Lohn in St. Paul contributed to this report.
(Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)