SEATTLE (AP) President Bush has the authority to fire the head
of a little-known agency that oversees caretaking of the
U.S.-Canada border, a federal judge ruled Friday.
U.S. District Judge Marsha Pechman rejected the claim of Dennis
Schornack, American head of the International Boundary Commission,
that the 1908 treaty that created the commission made no allowance
for firing commissioners.
Schornack, a Bush appointee, found himself in trouble when he
threatened to tear down a retaining wall built by a couple in
Blaine. Schornack said the wall stuck out three feet into a 10-foot
zone along the border that had to remain free of obstruction.
Property owners Herbert and Shirley-Ann Leu sued. Schornack has
said that after the Justice Department appeared ready to settle
with the Leus, he hired his own lawyers and filed a countersuit in
federal court. Soon after that, he was fired.
Schornack argued that he was trying to uphold the treaty he was
sworn to protect, and that the White House can't fire him. He
claimed that the treaty language did not allow for commissioners to
be removed except by death, resignation or disability.
Pechman said that was a strong argument, but she ultimately
disagreed.
``The treaties create obligations between (the U.S. and Canada)
that are enforceable through political and diplomatic channels, or
by other remedies available in international law, not by
individuals in domestic courts,'' the judge wrote.
The Bush administration has appointed a replacement for
Schornack, both on the Boundary Commission and for his second job
on the International Joint Commission, which handles boundary
waters issues. Schornack was paid about $135,000 a year.
Brian Hodges, an attorney who represents the Leus, said he was
pleased that their lawsuit could move forward.
``This has been an unfortunate distraction in bringing their
claims before the court,'' he said. ``It really didn't matter to us
which commissioner was defending it.''
Schornack's Washington, D.C.-based attorney could not
immediately be reached for comment after hours Friday.
The Leus, who live across from rural British Columbia, say they
built the 4-foot-high wall to keep their sloping backyard from
washing away into the shallow ditch that marks the 49th Parallel,
the border with Canada.
(Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)